Did Jesus Die on the Cross?

Did Jesus die on the cross?

The Qur'an says Jesus was not killed or crucified, and the apostles say they saw Him die and rise again; the gospel stands or falls on which is true.

Another was made to look like Him

The Qur'an says plainly that they did not kill Jesus and did not crucify Him, but "[another] was made to resemble him to them" (4:157, Sahih International), and Allah raised Him to Himself. The classical commentators explain that Allah cast Jesus' likeness on another man, who was crucified in His place, while Jesus was taken up alive. The witnesses saw a crucifixion and were mistaken about who hung there. Jesus lives with Allah and will return before the end, and only then die.

Not killed; Allah raised Him, and no more is said

Some Muslims keep to the verse's own words without the story of a substitute. The Arabic can be read as Yusuf Ali gives it, "so it was made to appear to them": the matter was made obscure, and those who claim to know "have no knowledge of it except the following of assumption." What is certain is that His enemies did not kill Him and that Allah raised Him up. How the appearance came about, the Qur'an does not say.

He was crucified but did not die there

The Ahmadiyya community, founded by Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, teaches that Jesus was nailed to the cross but taken down alive after a few hours, recovered from His wounds, met His disciples in the flesh, and later traveled east, where He died a natural death. They read the Qur'an's "they did not kill him" to mean that He did not die on the cross. Mainstream Sunni and Shia Muslims reject this teaching, as they reject the Ahmadiyya claims about their founder. No Ahmadiyya text was read for this page; this is a summary, not their words.

He died, was buried, and rose the third day

Jesus foretold His death and gave His life of His own will. He was crucified under Pontius Pilate, died before witnesses, and was buried; on the third day God raised Him, and He was seen alive by many over forty days. This is the gospel the apostles preached as of first importance: "that Christ died for our sins according to the scriptures".

What did Jesus say about His death beforehand?

What did the prophets foretell?

What did those at the cross see?

What did the first witnesses preach?

Antiquities of the Jews 18.3.3 (18.63-64), Whiston translation

And when Pilate, at the suggestion of the principal men amongst us, had condemned him to the cross,

A Jewish historian, writing in Rome about sixty years after the crucifixion, records that Pilate condemned Jesus to the cross. The passage as it stands also says "He was [the] Christ" and that "he appeared to them alive again the third day"; scholars dispute how much of it Josephus wrote and how much Christian copyists added, and the clause quoted here is cited on its own for that reason. (Date: general reference, not the linked page.)

Christus, from whom the name had its origin, suffered the extreme penalty during the reign of Tiberius at the hands of one of our procurators, Pontius Pilatus

A Roman senator and historian, hostile to the Christians, explains who they were when Nero blamed them for the fire of Rome in AD 64. He reports the execution as known fact; he does not say where he learned it. The Wikisource page does not name the translator (the wording is that of Church and Brodribb). (Date: general reference, not the linked page.)

Against Heresies 1.24.4 (Roberts and Rambaut translation)

but Simon, a certain man of Cyrene, being compelled, bore the cross in his stead

Irenaeus reports a Gnostic teacher of the second century who held that Christ did not suffer: Simon of Cyrene "was crucified, through ignorance and error, while Jesus himself received the form of Simon", and Jesus, "standing by, laughed at them." A story of a substitute on the cross was therefore told some four centuries before the Qur'an, by men who denied that Christ had a real body. Whether it lies behind any later account is a question this page leaves open.

Surah 4:157 (Sahih International)

And they did not kill him, nor did they crucify him; but [another] was made to resemble him to them. And indeed, those who differ over it are in doubt about it. They have no knowledge of it except the following of assumption. And they did not kill him, for certain.

The decisive verse. The clause rendered "[another] was made to resemble him" is translated differently: Pickthall "but it appeared so unto them"; Yusuf Ali "but so it was made to appear to them"; Arberry "only a likeness of that was shown to them"; Maududi "the matter was made dubious to them". Sahih International's bracketed "[another]" is the translators' addition; the substitute reading leans on it, and the others do not require it.

Surah 4:158 and 3:55 (Sahih International)

Rather, Allah raised him to Himself. And ever is Allah Exalted in Might and Wise.

In 3:55 Allah says, "O Jesus, indeed I will take you and raise you to Myself" (Pickthall: "I am gathering thee and causing thee to ascend unto Me"). The commentators read "take" in different ways: Ibn Kathir as "while you are asleep"; Tafsir al-Jalalayn, "raising you to Me away from the world without death"; Maududi, "to recall from mission."

Surah 19:33 (Sahih International)

And peace is on me the day I was born and the day I will die and the day I am raised alive.

Jesus, speaking as an infant in the Qur'an's account, speaks of a day He will die. Ibn Kathir explains: "He (`Isa) will live, die and be resurrected, just like the other creatures that Allah has created." Sunni teaching, following the hadith of His return (H7), places that death after it.

Sahih al-Bukhari 3448 (Book 60, Hadith 118)

surely (Jesus,) the son of Mary will soon descend amongst you and will judge mankind justly (as a Just Ruler); he will break the Cross

The return of Jesus in Sunni hadith. Abu Huraira links it to Qur'an 4:159, that the People of the Scripture will believe in Him "Before his death": on this reading Jesus has not yet died. English as printed on sunnah.com (translator not named on the page). Date: al-Bukhari died in 870.

Tafsir Ibn Kathir, on Qur'an 4:157

When the Jews came looking for `Isa, they found that young man and crucified him.

The best-known Sunni commentary tells the substitute story: in a house with His disciples, "Allah made the young man look exactly like `Isa," and Jesus was taken up through an opening in the roof. The story is the commentary's, not the verse's; other names for the substitute are given by other commentators. (Date: Ibn Kathir's century is from general reference.)

Study

  • Read Qur'an 4:157 in the translations given in H4. What does every translation say? Where do they differ, and what does the substitute story depend on?
  • What did Jesus say would happen to Him, and when did He say it (Mark 8:31; 10:33-34)? What does John 10:17-18 add about whose choice it was?
  • Who stood at the cross (John 19:25-26), and what did the soldiers, the centurion and Pilate each do to establish that Jesus was dead (Mark 15:37-45; John 19:32-35)?
  • Paul says he "received" the gospel of 1 Corinthians 15:3-8. Read Galatians 1:18-19. Whom had he met, and how soon after the cross?
  • Hebrews 5:7 says Jesus was "heard" when He prayed to the One able to save Him from death. Was He heard by being kept from dying or by being raised from the dead? Read Hebrews 2:9 and 13:20 before you answer.
  • Why does it matter for a Christian that Jesus truly died and rose? Read 1 Corinthians 15:12-20.

More illuminations · Harbinger's Lamp

⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
Press Start, click a point, or drag / scroll to explore · Ctrl + scroll to zoom
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
Press Start, click a marker, or drag / scroll to explore

⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library

A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project · Scripture quotations from the American Standard Version (1901)
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project
⌂ Library
A Harbinger Innovations Project