Study
Menahem — Character Study
The son of Gadi who smote Shallum and Tiphsah, reigned ten years in Samaria, and gave Pul king of Assyria a thousand talents of silver, taxed from the mighty men of wealth, to confirm the kingdom in his hand.
Menahem (2 Kings 15:14–22; 2 Kings 15:29; 2 Kings 8:12; 1 Chronicles 5:26; Hosea 5:13; Hosea 8:9; Hosea 12:1; Hosea 13:16; Amos 1:13)
Son of Gadi, king of Israel who paid tribute to Pul
The son of Gadi, who went up from Tirzah and smote Shallum, smote Tiphsah because it opened not to him, reigned ten years in Samaria and did evil, gave Pul king of Assyria a thousand talents of silver to confirm the kingdom in his hand, and was succeeded by his son Pekahiah.
Menahem the son of Gadi came up from Tirzah to Samaria, “smote Shallum the son of Jabesh in Samaria, and slew him, and reigned in his stead” (2 Kings 15:14). He reigned “ten years in Samaria” (2 Kings 15:17), c. 752–742 BC. Of the men who took the throne after Jehu’s house fell, he is the only one who slept with his fathers and passed it to a son (2 Kings 15:22). The verdict is the usual one, and it is strong: “he did that which was evil in the sight of Jehovah: he departed not all his days from the sins of Jeroboam the son of Nebat, wherewith he made Israel to sin” (2 Kings 15:18).
The text tells of him two things besides. The first is an act of cruelty at the start. “Then Menahem smote Tiphsah, and all that were therein, and the borders thereof, from Tirzah: because they opened not to him, therefore he smote it; and all the women therein that were with child he ripped up” (2 Kings 15:16). The reason given is that the town did not open to him. The text does not name the town’s ruler or say what Menahem demanded. It is the only deed of his own hand it records in detail. Elisha wept as he told Hazael of just such a deed to come (2 Kings 8:11-12), and Hosea says of Samaria that “their women with child shall be ripped up” (Hosea 13:16); Amos charges Ammon with the same crime against Gilead (Amos 1:13).
The second is the tribute. “There came against the land Pul the king of Assyria; and Menahem gave Pul a thousand talents of silver, that his hand might be with him to confirm the kingdom in his hand” (2 Kings 15:19). This is the first time in Kings that Assyria comes against Israel. Menahem did not pay it from his own treasury: “Menahem exacted the money of Israel, even of all the mighty men of wealth, of each man fifty shekels of silver, to give to the king of Assyria” (2 Kings 15:20). “So the king of Assyria turned back, and stayed not there in the land” (2 Kings 15:20). The silver bought a withdrawal. The text does not say it bought anything else, and in the days of Pekah, two reigns later, the king of Assyria comes again and “took Ijon, and Abel-beth-maacah… all the land of Naphtali” (2 Kings 15:29).
Pul is the name Kings uses; Chronicles names “Pul king of Assyria, and the spirit of Tilgath-pilneser king of Assyria” (1 Chronicles 5:26) together, and they are held to be one king, Tiglath-pileser III: the Babylonian Chronicle calls him Pul (Encyclopedia of the Bible, article Tiglath-Pileser). His own annals list Menahem of Samaria among the kings who brought him tribute (Ancient Near Eastern Texts, 3rd ed., p. 283). The year of that tribute is argued (see the note below).
A note on dates. The Bible gives Menahem ten years, beginning in Azariah’s thirty-ninth year (2 Kings 15:17). On the site’s standard chronology (Thiele) this is 752–742 BC. Some read the Assyrian record of his tribute as falling later than 742; the card keeps the standard dates and does not rest anything on the question.
Weaknesses
- Smote a king and took his throne
- Cruel to Tiphsah
- Departed not from the sins of Jeroboam
- Paid Assyria to confirm his kingdom
- Taxed his own mighty men
Themes
- The king who held on
- Cruelty at the start
- Assyria first appears
- Silver to confirm a kingdom
- The sin of Jeroboam
- The long fall of the north
Smites Shallum and takes the throne (2 Kings 15:14)
Menahem the son of Gadi goes up from Tirzah to Samaria, smites Shallum in Samaria, slays him, and reigns in his stead.
Smites Shallum and takes the throne
“And Menahem the son of Gadi went up from Tirzah, and came to Samaria, and smote Shallum the son of Jabesh in Samaria, and slew him, and reigned in his stead” (2 Kings 15:14).
Shallum had reigned a month (2 Kings 15:13). The text names Menahem’s father and the city he came from. It does not say what office he held or who followed him. It records no word of his.
Smites Tiphsah (2 Kings 15:16)
Because Tiphsah opened not to him, Menahem smites it and all that are in it, and rips up the women with child.
Smites Tiphsah
“Then Menahem smote Tiphsah, and all that were therein, and the borders thereof, from Tirzah: because they opened not to him, therefore he smote it; and all the women therein that were with child he ripped up” (2 Kings 15:16).
The text sets the town out from Tirzah, the city he had left (2 Kings 15:14, 16). Where the town lay is not settled by the text; Tiphsah is also the name of a city on the River in Solomon’s day (1 Kings 4:24), and Kings does not say they are the same. What it does say is what was done and why: the gates were closed, and the people paid for it, including those who could not have decided it.
The act is of a kind that Scripture names as a crime and a judgment. Elisha wept when he saw that Hazael would “rip up their women with child” (2 Kings 8:12). The LORD charged Ammon with it: “because they have ripped up the women with child of Gilead, that they may enlarge their border” (Amos 1:13). And He foretold it for Samaria: “Samaria shall bear her guilt; for she hath rebelled against her God: they shall fall by the sword; their infants shall be dashed in pieces, and their women with child shall be ripped up” (Hosea 13:16). The text of Kings gives no verdict of its own on the act apart from his general verdict (2 Kings 15:18).
Reigns ten years and does evil (2 Kings 15:17–18)
In the thirty-ninth year of Azariah Menahem begins to reign and reigns ten years in Samaria; he departs not all his days from the sins of Jeroboam.
Pul comes against the land (2 Kings 15:19; 1 Chronicles 5:26)
Pul the king of Assyria comes against the land; Menahem gives him a thousand talents of silver that his hand might be with him to confirm the kingdom in his hand.
Pul comes against the land
“There came against the land Pul the king of Assyria; and Menahem gave Pul a thousand talents of silver, that his hand might be with him to confirm the kingdom in his hand” (2 Kings 15:19).
The purpose is stated in the text: Menahem wanted Pul’s hand with him, and the aim, in the text’s words, was “to confirm the kingdom in his hand” (2 Kings 15:19). He had taken the throne by the sword. Now he paid a foreign king to stand with him. The text does not say Pul promised anything. It says he turned back.
Chronicles names the same king in two forms: “the God of Israel stirred up the spirit of Pul king of Assyria, and the spirit of Tilgath-pilneser king of Assyria, and he carried them away” (1 Chronicles 5:26), speaking of the tribes east of the Jordan. The two names are held to be the one king, Tiglath-pileser the third; the Babylonian Chronicle itself calls Tiglath-pileser Pul (Encyclopedia of the Bible, article Tiglath-Pileser).
Assyria’s own record. Tiglath-pileser III’s own inscription records, in Leo Oppenheim’s translation, I received tribute from... Menahem of Samaria (Ancient Near Eastern Texts, 3rd ed., p. 283). He is named among the kings who paid, with others. Assyria’s record is of a king receiving silver. Kings is of a king giving it, and of why: to confirm the kingdom in his hand.
Taxes the mighty men of wealth (2 Kings 15:20)
Menahem exacts the money of Israel, of each mighty man of wealth fifty shekels of silver, to give to the king of Assyria; the king turns back and stays not in the land.
Taxes the mighty men of wealth
“And Menahem exacted the money of Israel, even of all the mighty men of wealth, of each man fifty shekels of silver, to give to the king of Assyria. So the king of Assyria turned back, and stayed not there in the land” (2 Kings 15:20).
The tribute came from the rich, not from the king. A talent is three thousand shekels (the census silver in Exodus 38:25-26 shows it: a hundred talents and 1,775 shekels for 603,550 men at half a shekel each). A thousand talents at fifty shekels a man would therefore be sixty thousand men. The text gives no count, and this is arithmetic, not report. What the text does say is how wide it reached: “all the mighty men of wealth” (2 Kings 15:20), at fifty shekels of silver each.
The text does not say how the men of wealth answered. It says that they paid, and that the king went away.
Dies; Pekahiah reigns (2 Kings 15:21–22)
The rest of Menahem’s acts are written in the chronicles of the kings of Israel; he sleeps with his fathers and Pekahiah his son reigns in his stead.
Ephraim goes to Assyria (Hosea 5:13; Hosea 8:9; Hosea 12:1)
Hosea speaks of Ephraim going up to Assyria and making a covenant there; he does not name Menahem.
Ephraim goes to Assyria
Hosea’s words about Ephraim and Assyria are set beside Menahem’s tribute and not tied to it, because Hosea names no king.
“When Ephraim saw his sickness, and Judah saw his wound, then went Ephraim to Assyria, and sent to king Jareb: but he is not able to heal you, neither will he cure you of your wound” (Hosea 5:13).
“For they are gone up to Assyria, like a wild ass alone by himself: Ephraim hath hired lovers” (Hosea 8:9). And: “they make a covenant with Assyria, and oil is carried into Egypt” (Hosea 12:1).
What the prophet says of such trust, the book of Kings shows from within: silver paid, the king turned back, and the kingdom no safer. Within the same chapter, Assyria returns and takes the land of Naphtali (2 Kings 15:29).
Shallum (2 Kings 15:14)
The son of Jabesh, whom Menahem smote in Samaria and slew.
Pul (Tiglath-pileser) (2 Kings 15:19–20; 1 Chronicles 5:26)
The king of Assyria, to whom Menahem gave a thousand talents of silver to confirm the kingdom in his hand.
Pekahiah (2 Kings 15:22)
His son, who reigned in his stead.
Gadi (2 Kings 15:14)
His father; the text names him and says no more.
The mighty men of wealth (2 Kings 15:20)
The men of Israel from whom Menahem exacted fifty shekels of silver each.
Azariah (Uzziah) (2 Kings 15:17)
King of Judah, by whose years Menahem’s reign is counted, beginning in his thirty-ninth year.
Hosea (Hosea 5:13; Hosea 8:9)
The prophet who speaks of Ephraim going up to Assyria; he does not name Menahem.
Major sections
- 2 Kings 15:14–22